Sunday, June 21, 2009

"I am lying" True or False?

"I am lying" True or False? This much debated topic has sparked off an interest in many of us. Some people say that this statement is a paradox, others say no, it is true, or it is false. Yet others say that it is one of life's unanswerable mysteries.



I am of the opinion that the statement depends on the situation that it is used in. On its own, it is indeed a paradox, which I shall attempt to prove to you later on. However, When used in conjunction with other statements, it can either be contradictory or true.

Why is the statement a paradox? It is because if the person is telling the truth, he is lying. But if the person is lying, then he is telling the truth ...

However, it can be a contradiction when, say, I say that "I am a boy" followed by "I am lying". But if I say "I am a girl" follwed by "I am lying", then I am telling the truth, because I am obviously NOT a girl... right?

No comments:

Post a Comment